Understanding that risk and reward work together is crucial in investment, whether bonds or equity. Every investment involves a certain degree of risk.
However, taking too much risk for higher returns is not recommended because it can result in loss if the market moves against you.
That is where an approach like the ‘Barbell Strategy,’ which focuses on diversification, comes into play. This is widely used in the bond market. Let’s discuss it in detail.
What is a Barbell Strategy?
The Barbell Strategy is a portfolio construction method in which the available capital is invested in long—and short-duration securities while avoiding medium-term ones.
This strategy mainly applies to fixed-income portfolios and intends to exploit declining and rising interest rates.
The name ‘barbell’ comes from the strategy’s appearance on a graph, where the weightings of the short—and long-term investments resemble the weights of a barbell.
Barbell Strategy Examples
Let’s consider hypothetical barbell strategy examples.
Suppose you have Rs 10,000 to invest. You use the barbell strategy and invest Rs 5,000 in a 1-year bond that yields 2%. The balance you invest in a 20-year bond yielding 5%.
Here, the short-term bond provides flexibility, as the funds will be available for reinvestment in a year. Conversely, the long-term bond offers a higher yield. If interest rates rise, you can take advantage of those rates when the short-term bond matures. If rates fall, you still have the high-yielding long-term bond.
It is important to mention that the barbell strategy is not restricted to bond markets.
You can use it for equities as well. For example, you may split your portfolio between high-growth tech stocks (the long end of the barbell) and defensive stocks like healthcare (the short end).
This strategy requires active management and a careful balance of risk and reward. It is not suitable for all investors, but for those who can manage the risks, it can be a powerful tool in portfolio construction.
Drawbacks of the Barbell Strategy
The Barbell investment strategy of pairing high-risk and no-risk assets has its own set of downsides. These are:
- Limited Diversification: While the Barbell Strategy helps spread investments across high-risk and low-risk assets, it does not provide broad portfolio diversification. This strategy focuses on the two extremes of the risk spectrum, leaving out medium-risk investments that could offer balanced returns.
- Volatility: The high-risk investments in the Barbell Strategy can be very volatile. Due to market fluctuations and economic changes, predicting their long-run performance can be challenging.
- Active Management Requirement: Your Barbell Strategy requires constant monitoring and adjustments. As short-term bonds mature, you must purchase new bonds to maintain the balance. This process can be time-consuming and requires understanding various asset classes.
- Interest Rate Risk: Despite owning both long-term and short-term bonds, interest rate risk is still a concern. If long-term bonds are purchased with relatively low interest rates, they might lose value quickly if interest rates increase.
- Potential for Poor Performance: There is a risk of attaining the ‘worst of both worlds’ if both the risky and safe investments perform poorly. This could happen, especially in equity investments, for various reasons, such as picking the wrong stocks or rebalancing at inopportune times.
- No Intermediate-Term Exposure: The strategy avoids medium-term bonds, which could potentially offer balanced returns.
- Inflation Risk: Long-term bonds are more susceptible to rising inflation, which can erode the real return on these investments.
Alternatives to Barbell Strategy
In the bond market, you may try one of the following alternatives if not the barbell investment strategy.
- ‘Buy and Hold’ Strategy: In this strategy, you purchase individual bonds and hold them until maturity. The goal is to maximize the income-generating properties of bonds. The cash flow can immediately contribute to your income or be reinvested in other bonds or assets.
- ‘Quasi-Passive’ Strategy: This strategy aims to replicate the performance of a specific bond index. The portfolio is constructed to have the same risk and return characteristics as the index.
- ‘Immunization’ Strategy: This investment approach shields the portfolio from interest rate risk. It involves structuring the portfolio so that the duration of the portfolio’s assets matches the duration of its liabilities.
- ‘Dedicated’ Strategy: This strategy involves active bond portfolio management intending to outperform a specific benchmark. You make decisions based on your expectations of future interest rates, yield curves, and credit spreads. This strategy calls for a thorough knowledge of the bond market and strong analytical skills.
Conclusion
The Barbell Strategy requires investing in short-term and long-term securities while avoiding medium-term ones. It provides flexibility and higher returns but requires active management and comes with risks like volatility and limited diversification.
While only for some, it can be a helpful approach for those who can handle its complexities. Alternatives like the ‘Buy and Hold,’ ‘Quasi-Passive,’ ‘Immunization,’ and ‘Dedicated’ strategies may be more suitable for some investors, offering different ways to manage and invest in bonds.
To read more on investment and trading, check out the Dhan blogs.
